Woman Slams Ahmedabad Police’s ‘Request’ to Keep Windows Closed

When Pankti Jog, a resident of Ahmedabad requested the native police as as to if we lived in an authoritarian or feudal state and whether or not ministers have been kings below whose diktats the praja (the residents) needed to dwell below and never primarily based on democratic rules, she meant it. Actually.

Native police in Gujarat in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, issued directions to about 300 residents to maintain all their doorways and home windows of their houses closed for 3 hours. Nevertheless it took one girl, Pankti who for very legitimate causes raised the query.

The police round issued by Vejalpur police station learn, “very obediently we want to inform that revered dwelling minister of India Shri Amit Shah is visiting this space to inaugurate a group corridor on Sunday. Since he belongs to Z safety, his safety is necessary so on Sunday July 11, 2021, please hold all of your doorways and home windows of your residences or different houses, closed from 10 am to 1 pm”. The round was issued by the police inspector of Vejalpur, L.D. Odedara.

The order issued by Vejalpur police asking residents to maintain their doorways and home windows shut for 3 hours on Sunday. Picture: By association

The police served the discover to residents of no less than 5 residences equivalent to Swaminarayan Park Society, Swati Residences and others. About 300 residents needed to hold their doorways and home windows closed within the center class locality. The discover was served to those residences on July 10.

Vibes of India confirmed that there have been no such directions from Amit Shah’s safety crew, which includes of 55 personnel together with ten Nationwide Safety Commandoes.

Amit Shah is in Ahmedabad for 2 days. On Sunday, he inaugurated over ten programmes, and basis stone laying companies, for APMC, aanganwadis and sensible lecture rooms.

Gujarat goes to polls in December 2021. His inaugurations yesterday included a library, a civic centre, a water distribution venture apart from this group corridor inauguration at Vejalpur.



By the point you learn this story, Amit Shah, as per his schedule would have attended the Mangala aarti of Lord Jagannath at four am on Monday. That is an annual ritual that Amit Shah tries to stay by for many years.

After the Vejalpur police issued the round to totally different societies, chairmen and secretaries of those societies ensured that the request was strictly adopted. And this petrified Pankti, a 44-year-old woman dwelling on the third ground of the ‘A block’ of an residence in Vejalpur.

She has bronchial asthma since childhood and no recent air hurts her lungs badly and provides her bronchial asthma assaults. So, she went to the Vejalpur police station to inquire whether or not “we dwell in a democracy or are Ministers nonetheless the Kings”.

When Vibes of India contacted PI L.D. Odedra, Vejalpur police station, he stated, “We requested the residents, we didn’t power them. The request to maintain the doorways and home windows closed was made in order that the slightest motion close to the inauguration website may very well be seen. The buildings have been adjoining to the group corridor and that’s why we needed to take precautions”.

Pankti, an RTI activist who’s proud Goan-Gujarati despatched an e mail to the police commissioner’s workplace in Shahibaug concerning the ‘request’ and so they finally acted upon it. She additionally took to Fb and wrote:

Everybody has accepted has [t]he invisible rule of protecting their doorways and home windows shut when a politician is passing by means of an space. However there isn’t a such rule within the Z plus safety protocol. Police tells us one thing authoritatively and we imagine it.

At the moment the Vejalpur police has clarified that they’ve simply requested and never ordered us. The query just isn’t about protecting the home windows opened for 2 hours. However why ought to the Authorities determine how I dwell in my very own home.

Asserting that we dwell in a democracy and never an authoritative or feudal state, she wrote:

“At the moment, the federal government will inform me to maintain my home windows closed. Why ought to the Authorities determine this? At the moment it’s home windows, tomorrow this authorities will determine what I eat and the place I’m going,” she requested.

She additionally wrote:

“One other necessary level is {that a}[n] MP, MLA, Minister just isn’t a God. They’re the ten-headed demons we examine in Puranas. There isn’t any want that we worry them and fully give up to them. They’re public servants, public representatives. They should reply the individuals. They’re sure to reply us.

If all of the poor individuals promoting greens and different issues would have unitedly raised this problem, they wouldn’t have needed to hold their small companies shut for 3 consecutive days.

Extra fearsome than authorities guidelines, or strain from political staff, extra fearsome, worrying and dangerous is that we worry, we take heed to authorities meekly and we don’t increase questions.

“Round 1500 distributors work within the Vejalpur space and all of them needed to shut their work for 3 days. Who will compensate for his or her loss? It’s a identified pattern of the federal government to assault residents’ freedom by means of their protocols,” Jog informed Vibes of India on Sunday night time.

Vibes of India reached out to the Ahmedabad police commissioner Sanjay Srivastav who lashed out on the native police who issued this round. “Inspector Odedara is a senior and skilled police personnel and it wasn’t anticipated of him to indulge on this act. Essential motion will likely be taken in opposition to him,” he assured Vibes of India.

Senior Congress chief Arjun Modhwadia stated, “It’s the accountability of political leaders to create comfort for individuals, clear up their issues and never add to it. If politicians really feel unsafe in a public place they need to keep away from their frequent visits to inaugurate locations. The group corridor can function even when it isn’t inaugurated by the house minister.”

Union dwelling minister Amit Shah in Vejalpur. Picture: Vibes of India

He additionally highlighted this inappropriate behaviour of politicians a couple of weeks again when a 50-year-old girl died of post-COVID-19 problems in Uttar Pradesh’s Kanpur after the automobile ferrying her to the hospital was caught in visitors throughout President Ram Nath Kovind’s go to to the town.

Nonetheless, the BJP denied the incident and appeared aloof in regards to the police commissioner’s assertion of initiating motion in opposition to inspector Odedara. In reality, the Gujarat BJP dubbed this as regular observe.

“It’s the prerogative of the safety forces to safeguard our dwelling minister. And regardless of the individual the safety companies have been working towards in a similar way for the previous 30-40 years.  It’s regular observe. Even throughout the rath yatra, persons are requested to maintain their doorways and home windows shut and it’s for his or her security. As a civilian, I might abide by the foundations and would count on the identical from others,” Yamal Vyas, chief spokesperson, BJP, Gujarat stated.

Relating to Jog’s issues, he added, “She might have communicated her issues to the police and as her drawback is real; I’m positive police would have given her leeway.”

The query she posed was, “Until when shall we have now to go to plead for our fundamental freedom”.

Together with the put up, Pankti Jog posted a well-known poem by late Punjabi poet Avtar Singh Sandhu also referred to as Pash. It reads:

सबसे खतरनाक होता है
मुर्दा शांति से भर जाना
तड़प का न होना सब सहन कर जाना
घर से निकलना काम पर
और काम से लौटकर घर जाना
सबसे खतरनाक होता है
हमारे सपनों का मर जाना

To be buried below the silence is undoubtedly depressing,
However it’s nonetheless not essentially the most harmful.
To stay silent within the noise of corruption is undoubtedly depressing,
Studying covertly below the sunshine of a firefly is undoubtedly depressing,
However it’s nonetheless not essentially the most harmful.
Essentially the most harmful deed is to be full of useless silence,
Getting trapped within the routine of working from dwelling to work and from work to dwelling,
Essentially the most harmful accident is the dying of our desires.

This article was first printed on Vibes of India. It has been barely edited for model and readability.

Scroll to Top