Private car is a public place, masks mandatory even when driving alone: Delhi HC

It’s obligatory for individuals to put on a masks in a personal car even when they’re driving alone, the Delhi Excessive Court docket ordered on Wednesday, ruling {that a} non-public car on the roads can be lined beneath the definition of a public place.

The excessive courtroom additionally chided 4 attorneys who petitioned the excessive courtroom final 12 months in opposition to fines imposed by the Delhi Police for violating the masks rule, observing that compliance by attorneys encourages widespread individuals additionally to put on the masks wanted to curb the unfold of the coronavirus illness.

Justice Prathiba M Singh stated a personal car on the highway is a public place and it’s necessary to put on a masks even when one is travelling alone within the automobile.

“A masks acts as a suraksha kavach (protecting protect) which might forestall the unfold of the lethal virus,” the excessive courtroom stated, recalling that a number of specialists, docs and researchers have emphasised on the necessity to put on face masks proper from the early days of the pandemic.

Saurabh Sharma, a lawyer who was fined 500 for not carrying a masks final 12 months, had challenged the penalty in his petition filed in September final 12 months. Sharma stated the officers who imposed the tremendous had failed to offer any govt order to determine that it was necessary to put on masks whereas travelling alone in a personal car.

Sharma’s petition echoed a view that had been articulated by many individuals on and off social media who argued that folks must be allowed to take off their masks when driving alone.

The central authorities, which had first made it obligatory for individuals to put on masks in public locations in April final 12 months, didn’t take a stand and left it to state governments to see how they needed to implement the rule.

Residents of the nationwide capital, nevertheless, have reservations concerning the excessive courtroom ruling.

BS Vohra, president of East Delhi’s joint RWA discussion board, stated the choice was “not truthful”. “Now we have no possibility aside from to obey the courtroom order. However I believe carrying a masks whereas driving a automobile with all home windows closed shouldn’t be made necessary. When all home windows of a automobile are closed and the individual is within the car then it’s a non-public surroundings. The courtroom must also take cognisance of political rallies and protests the place hardly anybody is seen carrying masks or following social distancing norms,” Vohra stated.

Sanjay Rana, president of Higher Kailash-2 RWA, echoed Vohra’s assertion, and stated, “I really feel that masks must be necessary when an individual is driving alone with the home windows open; but when all windowpanes are closed and the driving force is alone within the automobile, then there must be no such compulsion. The courtroom  ought to do one thing about crowding in markets and different public locations because it poses extra hazard than a single man driving a automobile.”

A day earlier than Saurabh Sharma filed his petition, the Chandigarh administration informed police personnel to cease prosecuting individuals for not carrying masks if they’re alone within the automobile.

On this case, the Delhi authorities supported the prosecution of the attorneys throughout proceedings within the excessive courtroom.

It isn’t clear if the Delhi excessive courtroom’s ruling would persuade different states to evaluation their stand on this concern.

Political events appear to have opposing views on the ruling. Mudit Aggrawal, vice-president of Delhi Pradesh Congress Committee, stated, “I might urge the courtroom to rethink their resolution… This is able to result in pointless harassment and corruption with none precise advantages in controlling Covid-19 circumstances.” He added that by this logic, individuals should put on masks even at dwelling particularly if the door and home windows are open.

Bharatiya Janata Get together (BJP), nevertheless, welcomed the choice.

Delhi BJP spokesperson Praveen Shankar Kapoor stated, “We assist the courtroom’s ruling. Now we have even run masks and sanitiser distribution campaigns. We name upon our staff to encourage use of masks by distributing them wherever they’re wanted.”

Scroll to Top