Physical court lasted only 90 days during CJI SA Bobde’s tenure, will retire tomorrow

Chief Justice of Supreme Courtroom Justice SA Bobde will retire on Friday. He would be the first Chief Justice of the nation, whose majority of his tenure was spent listening to from Kovid lockdown and video conferencing. He was in a position to take a bodily listening to for 90 days throughout his 14-month tenure. When he retires on Friday, April 23, the court docket will likely be listening to solely the case of the accused.

Justice NV Raman will likely be changed by Justice Bobde of Nagpur. Nonetheless, he too will take cost at a time when the court docket is nearly closed. Solely pressing circumstances are being heard. Courtroom work has been restricted on account of Kovid 19 restrictions. Justice Bobde took cost because the Chief Justice of the nation on 14 November 2019. This was adopted by Christmas and New 12 months vacation in December. In January 2020, Kovid 19 began enjoying. After this, on March 24, the scenario deteriorated and there was a lockdown throughout the nation. The court docket needed to begin the listening to by way of video conferencing.

No judges may carry the highest court docket:

Within the matter of appointment of judges, Justice Bobde couldn’t carry a single decide to the Supreme Courtroom throughout his tenure. He made efforts to carry Tripura Excessive Courtroom Chief Justice Akil Qureshi to the Supreme Courtroom, however the dispute didn’t materialize on account of variations within the collegium. Other than this, he additionally wished to carry Andhra Pradesh Excessive Courtroom Decide Justice Nagaratna to the Supreme Courtroom, however he couldn’t succeed on this both. If Nagaratna had come to the Supreme Courtroom, she may have reached the publish of the primary girl Chief Justice of the nation. At current there are vacancies of 5 judges within the Supreme Courtroom. This case got here in 2015, when the Chief Justice was HL Dattu and no decide might be elevated to the Supreme Courtroom, though the explanation for this was the Nationwide Judicial Appointments Fee, 2014 pending the Courtroom’s inquiry into the constitutionality of the legislation.

Couldn’t hear crucial issues:

The impact of listening to by way of video conferencing was that the court docket couldn’t hear any essential points. Though some Structure Benches gave selections on necessary points like Land Acquisition Act, Justice Bobde was now not part of this Bench. Justice Bobde has not too long ago given some pointers for fast disposal of verify bounce circumstances.

This matter was in dialogue

Through the tenure of Justice Bobde, some circumstances got here beneath dialogue. These embody the matter of commenting on his motorbike journey. On this case, lawyer Prashant Bhushan was tried for contempt and he was additionally fined Rs 1 as punishment.

Scroll to Top