O2 concentrator case: Booking importers, makers counterproductive, says Delhi court, granting bail to four

A Delhi courtroom Wednesday granted bail to 4 individuals arrested for the alleged black advertising and marketing of oxygen concentrators whereas observing that reserving producers and importers with none proof was counterproductive and shall create a “additional shortage of already scarce medical gadgets”.

Chief Metropolitan Justice of the Peace Arun Kumar Garg granted bail to the accused Matrix Mobile Companies Ltd CEO Gaurav Khanna and Vice-President Gaurav Suri; together with enterprise growth govt Vikrant and Deputy Basic Supervisor, Satish Sethi.

The accused had been granted bail after furnishing private bond and surety bond in sum of Rs. 50,000 every. The courtroom will on Thursday pronounce the bail order of the fifth accused within the case, Hitesh.

The courtroom mentioned that regardless of repeated instructions by Delhi Excessive Courtroom, “the federal government isn’t coming ahead to cap the worth of important medical gadgets” nor any “regulation has been made by the federal government on the market of the identical by the importers to the federal government” for its “equitable distribution to the needy individuals for causes greatest recognized to the federal government”.

“Mere reserving of the producers/importers underneath the legal legislation with out a regulatory regime in place and with none proof simply to point out that the state is anxious concerning the issues of residents in procurement of life saving medical gadgets, in my thought of opinion, will probably be counter-productive and shall create an additional shortage of already scarce medical gadgets as it should discourage the producers and importers from pushing their assets in order to make the important medical gadgets out there to the needy residents,” the courtroom mentioned.

The courtroom clarified that it “shouldn’t be construed that this courtroom has any sympathy with the black entrepreneurs and hoarders of the important medicines/medical gadgets, nonetheless, the vacuum within the legislation must be stuffed up by the legislature or for that matter by the chief by issuing applicable rules.”

The courtroom in its order wrote that the investigating officer (IO) had appeared for the notifications throughout investigation, that means that the Part 3/7 of the Important Commodities Act was invoked within the FIR “with out the IO being certain concerning the existence of any such notification.”

“As soon as once more, such an method on the a part of police to ebook an individual first and to search for the legislation afterward, can’t in any respect be appreciated notably when it quantities to curtailment of the elemental proper of liberty of a citizen,” the courtroom mentioned.

The courtroom mentioned that “no prima facie case underneath part 420 (Dishonest and dishonestly inducing supply of property) of the IPC is made out in opposition to the accused a minimum of from the contents of the FIR”. The courtroom mentioned that “there isn’t any point out in all the case diary about any social media submit or every other aggrieved individual coming ahead with the criticism in opposition to the accused a minimum of within the case diaries.”

Moreover, the courtroom additionally clarified that, the IO is free to proceed the investigation “with out being influenced by the aforesaid observations which solely data the opinion of this courtroom”.

The accused have been booked underneath Sections associated to dishonest, Epidemic Ailments Act, and Important Commodities Act.

Police mentioned that they had recovered 524 concentrators from two prime eating places — City Corridor and Khan Chacha — in Khan Market, Nege Ju in Lodhi Colony, and Matrix’s warehouse in Chhatarpur’s Mandi Village. All of the eating places are owned by businessman Navneet Kalra.

Scroll to Top